“The lamest screen ‘twist’ since M. Night Shyamalan’s The Village.” Calum Waddell, SFX Magazine

“In the wake of Martin Scorsese’s recent movie about almost exactly the same thing, it’s tempting to rename this one Sh*tter Island.” Robbie Collin, News of the World

”Another misfire from Carpenter. Could this be his third and final strike?” Conor Mills, Little White Lies

“It soon becomes difficult to even care if the poor lass lives or dies.” Calum Waddel, Total Sci-fi Online

“It does appear as though the once-reliable filmmaker has lost his way in a seemingly insurmountable manner.” David Nusair, Reel Film Reviews